Buttermilk Hill Road Homes for Sale

Buttermilk Hill Road Homes for Sale

Welcome to Buttermilk Hill Road, a picturesque subdivision nestled in the heart of Pittsford, Monroe County, New York. This charming community offers a perfect blend of suburban tranquility and convenient access to urban amenities, making it an ideal place for families, professionals, and retirees alike.

Buttermilk Hill Road is characterized by its beautifully landscaped properties and tree-lined streets, creating a serene environment that feels like a retreat from the hustle and bustle of everyday life. The homes here are a delightful mix of architectural styles, each exuding its unique charm and character. From classic colonials to modern designs, there’s something for everyone in this sought-after neighborhood.

Residents of Buttermilk Hill Road enjoy a tight-knit community atmosphere while being just a stone’s throw away from the vibrant downtown Pittsford area. Here, you’ll find an array of boutiques, cafes, and restaurants, as well as access to the scenic Erie Canal, perfect for leisurely strolls or biking adventures. The highly-rated Pittsford Central School District further enhances the appeal of this area, making it a favorite among families seeking quality education for their children.

Currently, there are homes for sale on Buttermilk Hill Road, presenting a fantastic opportunity for prospective buyers to join this idyllic community. With a range of listings available, you can find the perfect home that suits your lifestyle and preferences. Don’t miss your chance to experience the charm and beauty of Buttermilk Hill Road—your dream home awaits!

Newest Buttermilk Hill Road Homes for Sale

$675,000
5 Beds 4 Baths R1697359 MLS
All the benefits of Village Living without the extra taxes! OPEN SUNDAY JULY 26th, 2026 from 12-2pm. This rambling Ranch, built in 1958, has been cared for by four families over the years and the pride of ownership exudes throughout. With a wide open floor plan and generously sized rooms this property was made for entertaining with multiple fireplaces, new over sized windows and hardwood floors throughout. You can feel the energy of former gatherings and celebrations over the years. In addition to the traditional living room, family room and kitchen the first floor also has two separate wings for sleepage. The first is dedicated to an owner suite that has all the essentials. Office, two walk-in closets and large updated bathroom and a primary bedroom that walks out to the patio in the back yard. Perfect for coffee with your sweet on those lazy Sunday mornings. The second wing has three bedrooms and two full baths each with hardwired lights and fans. There is going to be a battle for the first choice but each has plenty of room for privacy and storage. BUT. THATS. NOT. ALL! Yes almost 1000 feet in the lower level have been finished and is set up for yet another bedroom suite complete with egress window. There is also another full bath, recroom, built-in shelves and a work out area...and even with all of that you'll wonder how there is still so much storage. Oh and by the way there are options when it comes to laundry with hook-ups in the lower level as well as the owner's suite. The yard is almost 7/10ths of an acre and the neighborhood is to die for! Walk to the Village, walk to Sutherland High School or even walk to King's Bend Park.

42 Sunset Boulevard, Pittsford

Start Your Search